Articles and Archives

Most recent posting below. See other articles in the column to the right.

1 comment - Last on 03/15/2010

California High School Compelled Students to Protest

Today in the San Francisco Chronicle Debra J. Saunders makes an excellent point about last week’s March 4 protests: while they were supposedly a complaint about shortchanges to education, the protests themselves brought education to a halt. Ultimately, Saunders wrote, “The event showed how little educators and students value education.” 

She quotes Ian Glazman-Schillinger, a freshman student at Oceana High in Pacifica, California, who aptly called the protest a “temper tantrum” and said he had no desire to participate in it. But Oceana High School required all students to be involved in activism on March 4.

We have a copy of the letter that went out to all parents of Oceana students. It informed parents that “The Oceana staff has decided to change its regular school schedule on March 4th and participate in public education activities on this day,” and “we want Oceana students to be a part of the events.” The letter gave parents the opportunity to sign a permission slip for their child to take part in off-campus activities. Students without such permission, it said, “will be involved in activities at school.” Nowhere in the letter were there provisions to choose not to participate in the protests. It says, “Everyone will return to school by mid-morning. The remainder of the day will be filled with educational workshops on the budget crisis and the political process.” One of those “educational workshops” turned out to be a session in which students were strongly exhorted to either call or write a letter to their legislator.  

The March 4 demonstrations really were a temper tantrum in that they were loud, close-minded, and laughably self-contradictory. The case of the coercion at Oceana provides a perhaps emblematic glimpse of the activism required of students. Perhaps the only thing worse than observing a temper tantrum is being forced to throw one.  

See the NAS article “March Forth” for more background on the nationwide campus protests. 

Add a Comment

Why exactly isn't this a violation of the 13th Amendment?

Students are being required - without compensation or choice - to lobby for those who hold custody over them to be paid more.  That is slavery, little different than requiring the students to go mow teachers' lawns...


Take Back the Classroom from PowerPoint

Restrict PowerPoint use in teaching to pictures and videos, writes Jason Fertig. Too much PowerPoint usurps professors' authority and accustoms students to lazy thinking.

Collegiate Press Roundup 9-2-10

Student journalists examine topics from presidential speeches to campus smoking bans.

Will You Promote Diversity? Virginia Tech Tests Faculty Candidates’ Commitment

A major public university has fashioned a “diversity” litmus test for faculty hiring

FIRE Educates for Free Speech on Campus

FIRE will offer a Free Speech Seminar in NYC on September 14.

University Speaker Series: Arab Feminism, Black Feminism, and "A Southern Queer Love Story"...No Comment

A program on gender and diversity at the University of Richmond will explore "emancipatory ideas of social justice" this fall.

How Scholarships Morphed into Financial Aid

This excerpt from Jackson Toby's latest book, The Lowering of Higher Education in America: Why Financial Aid Should Be Based on Student Performance, will appear in the forthcoming fall issue of Academic Questions (vol. 23, no. 3).

Common Reading Controversy at Brooklyn College

Is Brooklyn College using freshman reading for ideological goals?

Question of the Week: How Many Colleges Should You Apply To?

To answer, leave a comment on this article, email us, or respond via Facebook or Twitter (no more than 140 characters).

Atlas Black Shrugs

The first comic book textbook combines management jargon and theories and packages them into a story about a slacker student's attempt to become an entrepreneur.
1 comment - Last on 08/27/2010

Collegiate Press Roundup 8-26-10

Student journalists have a look at the Ground Zero mosque controversy, reducing your carbon footprint and the pitfalls of "sexting."

A Regulatory Assault on For-Profit Higher Education

How the attacks on for-profit higher ed are squashing needed competition.

New Excellent Programs: Tocqueville Program and Center for Statesmanship

Check out our list of excellent programs as we add new ones at Indiana and Richmond.

The Glut of Academic Publishing: A Call for a New Culture

This article will appear in the forthcoming fall issue of Academic Questions (vol. 23, no. 3). A short version of this paper appeared under the title “We Must Stop the Avalanche of Low-Quality Research” in the June 13, 2010 Chronicle of Higher Education.
1 comment - Last on 08/25/2010

Building a 21st Century Syllabus

Professors these days have to cover their backs when writing syllabi, writes David Clemens.
2 comments - Last on 08/20/2010

Question of the Week: Why Did You Choose Your College?

We're starting a new "Question of the Week" series. We'll have a new higher-education-related question every week. To answer, leave a comment on this article, email us, or respond via Facebook or Twitter (no more than 140 characters).
2 comments - Last on 08/20/2010

Dictatorships and Double Standards, Part II

Professor Paquette responds to the controversy generated this summer after Hamilton College sought to censor his NAS article.

Real Ethics Education

Ethics courses should make moral decisions personal, argues Jason Fertig.

Collegiate Press Roundup 8-18-10

Student journalists tackle gay marriage, weird psycholgy studies and state liquor regulations.

5 Consequences of Administrative Bloat

What happens to higher education when universities are dominated by administrators?

Ravitch Repentant

Peter Cohee reviews Diane Ravitch's book, a partial volte-face, The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education.

 

Facebook

1 Airport Place, Suite 7
Princeton, NJ 08540-1532
Email:
Tel 609-683-7878
© National Association of Scholars. All rights reserved. Designed and Hosted by Princeton Online