Building Sandcastles or Filling Holes?

Ashley Thorne

On April 3 in a speech to education associations, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan urged, “We want you to hold us accountable and make sure that not only is every dollar wisely spent, but these dollars are significantly improving the life chances of children.” 

Andy Smarick, a former U.S. deputy assistant secretary of education and an adjunct fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, stepped right up to meet the request for accountability. Smarick has been tracking the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA, the stimulus package) and has published two special reports in a series, “Education Stimulus Watch,” on the Act’s implications for education.

In the first report, published in June, he noted that “the law's education components have been depicted as potentially among the most important engines for education reform in generations,” but predicted that ARRA would not actually result in the improvements to America’s schools. By September Smarick’s predictions were confirmed, and in his second report he took stock of the unfulfilled promises. He found that instead of financing constructive change, the money has been used to fund the status quo. ARRA, in other words, is filling holes when it should be building sandcastles.

This week a White House announcement quoted Duncan saying “"Initial reporting from states shows that education stimulus dollars have created or saved over 250,000 education jobs across the nation and have been invested in the kinds of reforms that will help today's students compete in a global economy,” But as the White House patted itself on the back, Smarick called its bluff. In a post at the Enterprise Blog he writes:

I’m quite surprised and disappointed that the White House would claim, “that ARRA funds are accomplishing both of these essential objectives (stabilization and reform)” and not even mention the GAO study or the report from the American Association of School Administrators that found quite the opposite.

The White House report was based on the administration’s analysis of recently received mandatory state filings under the ARRA. The public gets to see these documents at the end of the month; at that point we’ll be able to better sort out the actual preservation-reform blend of spending. Or as an excellent reporter at Education Week noted with pregnant understatement, “Given that most of the money has so far been used to get state K-12 funding levels up to the status quo, it will be most interesting to see what states and school districts report spending their money on.”

We applaud Smarick’s work in providing accountability for how the education funds of the stimulus bill are being allocated, and we look forward to reading his findings in the next report. 

  • Share

Most Commented

October 25, 2022


NAS President Peter Wood Addresses the Pending Racial Preferences Cases

Read NAS president Peter Wood's remarks on the upcoming Supreme Court cases, which he presented at a meeting of "Oasis," an informal group of academics and intellectuals based in......

July 25, 2022


Against Transgenderism

The ideology of transgenderism strives to slam shut any door that offers opposition to its attempts to acquire power and control. This statement explains our opposition to such an ideology i......

October 20, 2022


NAS Statement on Nomination of Ben Sasse for University of Florida President

We believe that Senator Sasse would make an excellent president of the University of Florida, and we urge the Board of Trustees to follow the search committee’s recommendation....

Most Read

May 15, 2015


Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

October 12, 2010


Ask a Scholar: What is the True Definition of Latino?

What does it mean to be Latino? Are only Latin American people Latino, or does the term apply to anyone whose language derived from Latin?...

May 12, 2017


Harvard Prepares to Host All Black Graduation

Is Harvard's all black graduation a benign trend or a step backwards? ...