Academic Questions

Summer 2019

Volume 32 Issue 2

Two Victories for Academic Freedom

Peter Bonilla

Peter Bonilla tells the heartening story of two recent court cases that resulted in legal victories for the protection of free speech rights. In one case a federal court addressing a public university and in another, a state's highest court addressing a private university upheld free speech protections for faculty members sanctioned for expressing views their administrations disliked.

The Confucius Institutes

Rachelle Peterson

Confucius Institutes—which present themselves as exemplars of cultural exchange with the U.S., but in reality allow China to monitor American professors, pressure universities, and seek out opportunities for academic espionage—have had a large role in Chinese attempts to influence U.S. institutions. The National Association of Scholars has had a similarly large role in shutting them down.

Due Process, DeVos, and the Courts

KC Johnson

U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos has made restoring campus due process and the presumption of innocence in sexual harassment cases a top priority. DeVos has proposed regulations that use language closely tied to that of the federal courts. In the meantime, a wave of lawsuits against colleges and universities by accused students has revealed a desire on the part of the courts to correct a badly flawed system.

Politicized Science

David Randall

From mandating social justice bona fides for faculty candidates to enforcing climate alarmist groupthink in “gold standard” journals, the diversity creed is threatening science pedagogy and scientific advance. David Randall describes the current state of affairs and ponders the possibility that we are losing the last redoubt of objectivity on our campuses.

Saving Remnants: Where Western Civ Thrives

Glenn Ricketts

The Great Books of the Western Canon were once ubiquitous in American undergraduate education, the crucial entry way to humanity’s “Great Conversation” of ideas. That ended in the latter part of the twentieth century. But “Western Civ” survives. Glenn Ricketts provides a survey of existing programs where Western civilization is still part of the core curriculum.

Harvard Hoist on Its Own Petard?

John Rosenberg

With the antidiscrimination suit brought against it by Students for Fair Admissions, Harvard University finds itself front and center in the affirmative action battle zone. It’s deserved. From the Bakke case that started it all to the current lawsuit, Harvard has played a conspicuous role in denuding the merit-based system.

Diversity Discontent

Charles Geshekter

Colleges and universities are enforcing ever more stringently an impoverished view of diversity that says members of genetically ascribed groups share a rigid set of thoughts, attitudes, and experiences. Historian Charles Geshekter explains that in the wake of Supreme Court Justice Lewis Powell’s 1978 deification of “educational pluralism,” it couldn’t have been otherwise.

Queer Criminology: New Directions in Academic Irrelevance

Mike Adams

Criminologist Mike Adams warns that requiring students to spend time studying such an indistinct field as "queer criminology" may be hurting their job prospects, and turning a scholarly discipline over to advocacy.

Object of Inquiry: Psychology’s Other (Non-replication) Problem

John Staddon

Psychological science, currently embroiled in a “replication crisis,” has a more difficult problem concerning the use of statistics. Psychologist John Staddon points out that deducing the causes of individual behavior from group studies, particularly when there is variability within groups, is a fatal error of psychological research today.

Academic Freedom and the Central European University

Stephen Baskerville

The George Soros-founded Central European University is closing its doors in Budapest. Apparently, there are democratically elected leaders in the world that don’t see the efficacy of spending tax dollars on grievance study activism and social justice palaver.

On Ethnic Cleansing and Revisionist Russian History

John K. Chang

Jon K. Chang reminds us that important parts of the American academy remained highly sympathetic toward the Soviet Union, long after Stalin's deadly reign became widely known. So intent were the leading scholars of Soviet studies on painting a benign picture of the Soviets, many took pains to sugarcoat Stalin's brutal removal of Soviet ethnic minorities.

The Liberal Arts as Magic and as Paradox

John Agresto

John Agresto tells us that today’s liberal arts critics are wrong to discard the past, to teach that the best that has been said or written can only burden us with “old ideas and antique prejudices.” A more generous understanding of the liberal arts not only illuminates but can “carry us ahead not simply against the winds of public opinions and prejudices but against the stifling forces of academia itself.”

The Futility of Gun Control as Crime Control

Barry Latzer

“There is an indisputable connection between the prevalence of firearms in the United States and killings,” writes Barry Latzer. But given the “historical popularity of firearms, explicit legal support (the Constitution’s Second Amendment), the effective lobbying of the National Rifle Association, and the efficacy of guns for self-defense,” confiscatory gun control laws are unlikely. Better we take targeted, incremental measures where there are policy gaps we know we can close.

The One Way Street: Misunderstanding Fascism

Paul Hollander

The late Paul Hollander reviews How Fascism Works: The Politics of Us and Them, by Jason Stanley, Random House, 2018, XXIX+218 pp., $17.68 hardbound.

Gay Marriage as a Status Symbol

Robert Maranto

A review of From Tolerance to Equality: How Elites Brought America to Same Sex Marriage, by Darel E. Paul, Baylor University Press, 2018, 245 pp., $39.95 hardbound.


David Randall

Poems on "each persuading each" and the legacy of great conversation. 

Thank you for Sharing

Michael Lurie

A new poetry submission on the "foolish ideas of a generation."

Join to read
Academic Questions.

Become a member to read every issue.

Join to Read
Renew your membership