Peer Review: The Gold Standard?

Peter Wood

The Washington Post just ran an opinion piece on Why we shouldn’t take peer review as the ‘gold standard.’” The NAS agrees that flawed peer review is a large problem--it's a major contributor to the irreproducibility crisis of modern science. The opinion piece, unfortunately, made its point by a misguided attack on Dr. Willie Soon. NAS President Peter Wood sent this letter to The Washington Post to defend Soon, and point out where the problems of peer review truly lie.

Regarding the August 1 Outlook piece “Why we shouldn’t take peer review as the ‘gold standard’”: Thacker and Tennant recycle a 2015 hit-piece by environmental activists against Dr. Willie Soon.  They are trying to demonstrate that peer review has problems, but their missile goes off target. They smear Soon for accepting research funding from fossil fuel interests, but the source of funding has nothing to do with the quality of science except in the minds of conspiracy theorists. 

Peer review suffers from major defects. Articles that are rife with problems sail through because of cheer-leading by like-minded peer reviewers.  The essence of the problem is groupthink.  In some fields up to half of published articles are irreproducible, i.e. scientifically worthless.  That's not true of Dr. Soon's work, which has withstood relentless review by partisan scientists who wish they could discredit its substance, but are left taking potshots at his sources of funding.  Any notable dissenter—any Willie Soon—is more likely to be the victim of a flawed peer review system than its beneficiary.

Respectfully,

Peter Wood, President

National Association of Scholars

  • Share

Most Commented

August 17, 2021

1.

Fermilab Concedes to Woke Physicists

Known for its powerful particle accelerator, Fermilab epitomizes American physics research. But after accusations of racism, a group of woke physicists now controls the lab....

May 15, 2015

2.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

July 7, 2021

3.

CRT in Higher Education: Is a Day of Reckoning Coming for the University of Texas?

UT President Hartzell has been content to ignore critics regarding his institution's plunge into wokeism. With a Texas Legislature special session coming up, he may be in for a rude awak......

Most Read

August 17, 2021

1.

Fermilab Concedes to Woke Physicists

Known for its powerful particle accelerator, Fermilab epitomizes American physics research. But after accusations of racism, a group of woke physicists now controls the lab....

May 15, 2015

2.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

October 12, 2010

3.

Ask a Scholar: What is the True Definition of Latino?

What does it mean to be Latino? Are only Latin American people Latino, or does the term apply to anyone whose language derived from Latin?...